What Are Real Estate Comps?
When you’re buying or selling a home, one of the most important factors in determining value is real estate comparables, often referred to as “comps.” Whether you’re a first-time buyer, a seasoned investor, or simply curious about how property values are assessed, understanding what comps are and how they work is essential. In this blog, we’ll break down what real estate comps are, what they can tell you, and when they should influence your decisions.
What Are Real Estate Comps?
Real estate comps (comparables) are recently sold homes that are similar to the property in question in terms of size, location, condition, and features. These properties are used to determine the fair market value of a home. The goal is to find homes with similar characteristics to ensure the comparison is accurate. For example, a 3-bedroom home with 2 bathrooms in a specific neighborhood would be compared to other homes of the same type within a certain radius, typically 1 to 2 miles.
Real estate professionals, including agents and appraisers, rely on comps to assess the value of properties and guide their clients in making informed decisions.
Why Are Comps Important?
Understanding comps is crucial for both buyers and sellers. Here’s why:
- Price Accuracy for Sellers
If you’re selling your home, comps help you set the right asking price. Too high, and your home could linger on the market. Too low, and you may leave money on the table. By analyzing recently sold homes with similar features and characteristics, you can determine a competitive yet realistic price.
- Fair Purchase Price for Buyers
As a buyer, knowing the comps helps ensure that you’re not overpaying for a property. Without comps, it’s easy to get swept up in a bidding war or purchase a home at a price above its actual value. By comparing homes with similar attributes, you can make more informed offers and avoid paying more than a house is worth.
- Appraisal Purposes
Lenders typically require a home appraisal when you’re getting a mortgage. The appraiser uses comps to verify that the property you’re purchasing is worth the loan amount. If the home’s value doesn’t align with the comps, the lender may require a lower loan amount or even refuse financing. For sellers, this can also affect how quickly you can close the deal.
What Information Do Real Estate Comps Provide?
Real estate comps provide insight into several key aspects of a property’s value, such as:
- Sale Price
The most straightforward comparison is the sale price of similar homes. This gives you an idea of what buyers have been willing to pay in the area for properties like yours.
- Square Footage
Comparing square footage is important because it directly influences value. A larger home with more livable space generally commands a higher price.
- Location
The location of comps is one of the most critical factors. Properties in the same neighborhood or school district tend to have similar value. Even within a city, different areas or even streets can have vastly different property values due to things like proximity to amenities, or overall neighborhood appeal.
- Condition and Age
Homes that are recently renovated or in better condition tend to be priced higher. Comps also take into account the age of the home, as newer properties might carry more value due to fewer maintenance concerns, but not always.
- Amenities and Features
Additional features like updated kitchens, large yards, pools, or eco-friendly upgrades (like solar panels) can significantly impact a property’s value. Comps will often be filtered to ensure these features align closely between the subject property and those being compared.
- Timeframe of Sale
Real estate values fluctuate over time, so comps should be based on homes sold in the last 3-6 months, or ideally, 1-2 months for the most accurate reflection of current market conditions. If the property you’re comparing has been sold in the last year or longer, the data may not accurately represent current trends.
When Do Comps Matter?
Real estate comps play a pivotal role in a variety of situations.
Here are a few times when you should be paying extra attention to them:
- Setting the Listing Price for Sellers
If you’re selling your home, accurate comps are vital in determining the correct asking price. While you may have a sentimental attachment to your property, comps are based on what buyers in your area are willing to pay for similar properties. Relying on comps will help you position your home competitively and avoid overpriced listings that risk sitting on the market for too long.
- Making an Offer as a Buyer
As a buyer, comps help you gauge the fairness of the asking price. If you find that homes similar to the one you’re interested in have recently sold for significantly less, this can give you leverage in negotiating with the seller.
- Refinancing Your Mortgage
If you’re considering refinancing, an appraiser will use comps to determine your property’s value. The better the comps (i.e., the more favorable the comparisons), the better your chances of getting a favorable refinance offer. This is especially important if you’re hoping to pull equity out of your home.
- Home Inspections and Appraisals
Even though appraisers and inspectors perform separate functions, both use comps to assess property value and condition. Comps will give you an idea of how your property compares to others and what changes (if any) might increase its value.
When Do Comps Not Matter?
While comps are incredibly valuable in many situations, there are instances where they may not be the best or only factor to consider:
- Unique or Luxury Properties
When dealing with unique or luxury properties, comps may not always offer an accurate representation of value. These types of homes often have rare features (e.g., custom architecture, expansive land, or high-end finishes) that make direct comparisons difficult. In these cases, the property’s intrinsic value, its rarity, and even the personal desires of potential buyers can play a larger role.
- New Construction Homes
New homes may not have many comparable properties in the area because they are newly built. In these cases, builders may set the price based on construction costs, amenities, and demand rather than solely relying on comps. Additionally, newly constructed homes can sometimes outperform comps due to the appeal of modern features, energy efficiency, and warranties.
- Fluctuating Markets or Unusual Conditions
When the market is in flux—such as during a housing bubble, recession, or sharp changes in interest rates—comps may not fully capture the shifting dynamics of the market. In these uncertain times, broader economic indicators and market trends can play a more significant role in determining property values than recent comparable sales. That’s why it’s essential to have a trusted real estate professional by your side. A local expert like Maconite Joanna “JoJo” Jones, who knows the ins and outs of the Macon and Middle Georgia markets, can provide valuable insights and help you navigate these fluctuations with confidence.
- Off-Market Deals
In some cases, real estate deals don’t go through traditional MLS listings, meaning there are no publicly available comps for those properties. In this case, using other factors like seller motivations, condition of the property, or private appraisals may be necessary.
Conclusion: How to Use Comps Wisely
Real estate comps are an indispensable tool for understanding the value of a property. They help set realistic expectations, guide negotiations, and support fair appraisals. However, it’s essential to remember that comps are not a one-size-fits-all solution. They are just one part of the overall picture, especially when dealing with unique properties, changing markets, or new developments.
By understanding how to interpret comps—and when to look beyond them—you’ll be in a stronger position, whether you’re buying or selling a home. Be sure to work with a skilled real estate professional like Joanna “JoJo” Jones who can provide you with up-to-date, accurate comps and help guide your decision-making process.
If you’re ready to dive into the real estate market, whether as a buyer or seller, call JoJo today to discuss your options and get expert advice on using comps to your advantage!
Sign up for Market Reports
Call JoJo at 478-731-1302